Smartwatches Overestimate Caloric Burn (And Struggle More With Certain Body Sizes)

Apple, Garmin, Samsung, and Fitbit were tested against lab equipment. Calorie estimates missed by up to 25%, and the error grew with...

Smartwatches Overestimate Caloric Burn (And Struggle More With Certain Body Sizes)

Apple, Garmin, Samsung, and Fitbit were tested against lab equipment. Calorie estimates missed by up to 25%, and the error grew with body fat. Here’s how to make sense of the data (and why your wearable still can be helpful).

Welcome to the positive corner of the internet. We’re here to make your life healthier, happier, and less stressful. At the bottom of each email, we explain our editorial process, stance on AI, and partnership standards.

If you were forwarded this message, you can get the free daily email here.

Today’s Health Upgrade

  • Arnold’s 12 workout challenge

  • Number you won’t forget

  • Can red light help hair, skin, and joints?

  • Live event today: Train with Ketchell

  • Weekly wisdom

Arnold’s Corner
Arnold’s 12 Workout Challenge (Finish The Year Strong)

This is the time of year when a lot of people give up on themselves.

You know I hate when you give up on yourselves. The motto for almost everybody is: “Wait until next year.”

You know I hate waiting.

And we all know what happens to January resolutions. The statistics show that most of the resolutions you made in January are probably in your rear-view mirror — and not as accomplishments.

That's because January isn't magic. It's just another month. 

People convince themselves it's different because it's a fresh start. And then they make fresh starts every year that end with fresh stops.

The magic is in you, not in the calendar. The difference is in you, not in next year.

As soon as you figure that out, your whole life changes.

I can help you figure it out. But I can't do the real magic for you, because the real magic is action.

12 Workouts. Four Programs. Do it, And Your App Is Free.

Luckily, I've found a blueprint that incentivizes action.

This summer, for my birthday, we did something nobody in fitness does. We didn't give you a discount. We gave you a deal: pay for the Pump Club app, finish your programs, and we pay you back — up to $100. 

That means we were giving the app away to anyone who put in the work. 

Yes, we actually lose money when we give the app away for free. No, we don’t care what our CFO thinks. We care that you’re training.

You know what happened? The people who joined didn't do what most people do. They didn't sign up, feel good about it, and disappear.

They showed up. They trained. They are working out more than our typical member, and our typical member already trains harder than most. 

We've already paid back hundreds of thousands of dollars as people finish their first programs.

So we're doing it again. But this time there's a catch.

You don't get to wait for January.

No more “new year, new me.”

New you…right now.

Here's the deal. No up-front discount like you'll see all over social media this week. Something better.

Do your first 12 workouts before January 1, and you get $50 back. Then finish four programs in your first year, and you earn back the rest. All automatically refunded to your card.

That's a full year of Pump Club for free. The only thing you pay with is sweat.

12 workouts before January 1. If you start now, that’s about two a week.

You can do that. I know you can do that.

Finish 2026 strong, and you walk into 2027 already ahead of everybody who's still waiting.

Let's go.

P.S. You have to sign up at this link because we cannot refund people who finish programs through Apple App Store or Google Play subscriptions.

Fitness
Number You Won’t Forget: 9%

You finish a hard workout, glance at your wrist, and see 400 calories burned. You feel great about yourself. And the success feels like permission for a bigger dinner. 

Unfortunately, while a wearable can do a lot of good, research suggests they are consistently inaccurate at measuring calorie burn. 

In fact, calorie estimates landed within 3% of the true number of calories burned in only 9% of lab tests. And heart rate hit that mark 57% of the time. You can’t even create a simple formula to adjust for it because wearables over- and under-estimate caloric burn. 

And now a new study confirms that as much as technology improves, it still isn’t as accurate as the numbers make it seem.

In the latest research, researchers had adults wear an Apple Watch, Fitbit, Samsung, and Garmin at the same time during 10 minutes of interval cycling. Then they compared each watch’s calorie estimate with what the lab actually measured from the air people breathed in and out.

Three of the four devices overestimated. Garmin overestimated by 69 calories, Samsung by 57, and Apple by 22. Fitbit looked close on average, but only after researchers threw out seven readings (about 13% of its sessions) for “device glitches,” including some data that only showed 1 calorie burned for the entire ride.

Overall, calories were off by 15% to 25% on average, with some sessions showing even greater inaccuracy.

What caught our eye was that errors grew as body fat increased.

That means the people most likely to use a watch to manage weight may be getting the least reliable number.

Scientists believe this might occur because the calorie-burning numbers are built on a model based on heart rate, movement, and age, height, and weight. And those models were calibrated on leaner people.

Again, that doesn’t mean the watch has no value. And most have multiple functions, such as steps, heart rate, HRV, and trends that can help you identify behaviors that do or don’t work for you. 

Knowing the technology's limitations also helps. If you decide to eat a little extra because of the number on the watch, it helps to know that number could be misleading or inaccurate. 

Together With Celluma
Can Red Light Help Your Skin, Joints, and Hair?

Most of us handle aging one complaint at a time. A cream for the lines by your eyes. A heating pad for the knee that grumbles on the stairs. A shampoo that promises thicker hair and mostly delivers a nice smell. Three problems, three fixes, one very crowded bathroom drawer.

Your skin, your knees, and your hairline don’t age on separate schedules. So why treat them with three different gadgets?

The foundation of better aging is exercise, nutrition, sleep, and avoiding behaviors like smoking and alcohol. And the research on red light suggests a simpler way to support your foundational anti-aging efforts beyond those foundational habits. 

Researchers think red and near-infrared light is absorbed by your mitochondria, the part of each cell that makes energy. More energy may give cells more to work with for the upkeep they already do every day.

A phone at 15% still works. It just starts closing apps to save power. The theory is that cells running low behave similarly, and light helps top them back up.

That possible shared mechanism may be why the same light keeps showing up in three very different areas of research.

In a double-blind trial of 76 adults, eight sessions of clinical-grade red and near-infrared LED light reduced wrinkles by up to 36% and improved elasticity by up to 19% compared with baseline. Those were the best results among the treatment groups.

A separate analysis of 22 randomized trials and more than 1,000 people with knee osteoarthritis found that light therapy at the recommended doses cut pain by about 19 points on a 100-point scale compared with placebo. Lower doses were less effective. 

And in a placebo-controlled trial, women who used an LED helmet at home for 16 weeks increased their hair counts by about 48%, compared with about 11% in the placebo group. The study was small and was funded by the device maker, but men using the same setup saw similar gains.

So, can red light help with your skin, joints, and hair? It can, as long as you’re clear about what to expect, use it for the right problems, and get the right light at the right dose. 

Everyone lumps red light into one category, but light only works at the right dose, and it’s hard to know whether your home device gets there. 

Few brands publish independently tested output, and the early independent tests show that advertised numbers can be off. Sometimes the wavelength is wrong. Sometimes the panel is flat, so it sits inches away from curved spots like a knee or scalp, and intensity drops fast with distance. Or the sessions are too short to match what the studies used. And none of these results showed up overnight. They took weeks of consistent use.

That’s why, if someone wants to use light therapy, we recommend Celluma NOVA. It uses blue, red, and near-infrared light and is FDA-cleared for five uses, including wrinkles, temporary relief of minor joint pain and stiffness, and hair growth. 

The patented panel flexes so it sits right against your face, scalp, knee, or shoulder. Each 30-minute program is set to match the clinical research, so there’s no guessing. It weighs about a pound, runs on a rechargeable battery, and comes from the most awarded LED brand, used by licensed professionals in more than 100 countries.

One device. Five concerns. A lot less drawer space.

Right now, APC readers can take advantage of Celluma’s Cyber Sale, which runs through December 2, with savings of up to $2,250 on select devices and no code needed. The NOVA is $160 off, and it’s HSA/FSA eligible, which can mean an average of about 30% in additional pre-tax savings.

Community
Train With Ketch

On Monday, we shared the workout he’ll perform. You can find it here if you want to follow along or try it yourself. 

Or just show up, say hi, and ask him questions while he powers through his workout.

If nothing else, you’ll learn about some Pump Club principles like “first set mindset,” how to make any workout harder, and why you don’t need long to get a great workout.

The workout starts at 5 am PST/8 am EST, and you can join and watch here. 

Mindset
Weekly Wisdom 

❝

“If there is no struggle, there is no progress.”

Frederick Douglass

No matter what you might think, the road to success feels similar for almost everyone.

It’s easy to look at someone in their “after” state, where things seem easier. But the reality is that at some point, motivation fades, novelty wears off, real-life stressors pile up, and the journey feels like crawling through quicksand. 

People who achieve their goals don’t avoid the “hard phase.” They learn to succeed despite it.

In the gym, the weight that felt easy one day might now take everything you’ve got, and the mirror hasn’t caught up to the effort yet.

In those days, it feels like, What’s wrong with me? 

The reality: Hard is what progress feels like from the inside, and it tends to peak right before the changes start to show.

So when the work gets more challenging, you’re probably right where you’re supposed to be.

Douglass said the words above in 1857, in a speech about the fight to end slavery. He argued that freedom had never been handed to anyone who asked politely. In the same speech, he said that people who wanted freedom but condemned the agitation it required wanted “crops without plowing up the ground.”

What he was talking about is far different and heavier than most personal battles or struggles, inside or outside the gym. 

But there’s a foundational truth that anything worth having often pushes back.

Struggle shows up during real progress, and it can feel like there’s a problem.

The only problem is that achieving your goals isn’t necessarily complicated, but it’s not easy either. 

As Arnold loves to say: Simple, not easy. 

How something feels can tell you a lot about how much you’re asking of yourself. 

Ease shows up when you’ve mastered something, and it also shows up when you’ve stopped pushing. 

A hard week can mean growth or a real problem, and the feeling can’t tell you which.

Researchers tested what happens when people learn to read discomfort differently. In a study on improv students, before an exercise, some students were told their goal was to feel awkward and uncomfortable because that feeling meant the exercise was working. Those students took more risks than classmates who got other instructions. 

In four follow-up experiments, people who viewed discomfort as a signal of growth stayed more consistent with emotionally difficult tasks longer.

That doesn’t mean all friction is good. But productive struggle has a shape. 

The burn at the end of a set fades a minute or two after you rack the weight. Soreness peaks a day or two later and then clears. A new movement feels clumsy until one day it feels a little less clumsy. Hunger before dinner nags you and then leaves once you learn to manage the signals, ditch bad habits, and eat more fulfilling foods. 

Harm acts differently. With fitness, sharp joint pain or changes in how you move differ from soreness. Or maybe it’s dread that grows week after week in a work environment. Actions that put you in real harm or danger are different from those that challenge your comfort zone. Those deserve an adjustment or a professional’s opinion, and pushing through them isn’t always the answer.

Turn Wisdom Into Action

The next time things get hard, and you start to doubt, take two minutes and write a note with two headings.

“Normal hard:” list what you expect to feel if the plan is working. Be specific. 

“Stop signals:” write down real signs of danger. Again, this is not about discomfort or a challenge, but a real threat. 

When something feels hard, check the note before you change the plan. If it’s on the first list, it’s part of the friction that comes with growth, so keep going. Anything from the second list gets more attention, a possible adjustment, with no guilt attached. 

You’re deciding what hard means while you’re calm, so a rough moment doesn’t get to decide for you.

Everyone wants to achieve something great in their life. Those who do often realize that the road to a better start out bumpy and uncomfortable before it feels more paved and stable. 

And that’s it for this week. Thanks for being a part of the positive corner of the internet. And remember: don’t wait to make a change. Take action on any goal, don’t quit in the hard moments, and the results will come. Go be better every day. 

-Arnold, Adam, and Daniel

Better Today

Take any of these tips from today’s email and put them into action:

1. Arnold’s 12 Workout Challenge

It’s simple: This year, Arnold is paying you back to help you finish the year strong. Do 12 workouts before January, and you get paid back $50 — and you could even get the Pump Club app for free if you finish 4 programs in a year. Most fresh starts fail because people wait for January. Join the app, and get a head start on success.

2. Your Smartwatch Overestimates Calories Burned

Smartwatch calorie numbers are estimates that are usually inaccurate. In a 2026 PLOS One study, Apple, Garmin, Samsung, and Fitbit watches missed lab-measured calorie burn by 15% to 25% on average, and the error grew as body fat increased. That doesn’t make your watch useless. Heart rate is much more reliable than calories. And trends over time matter more than any one reading.

3. How Red Light Can Support Healthy Skin, Joints, and Hair.

Controlled trials show red and near-infrared light reduced facial wrinkles up to 36%, lowered knee osteoarthritis pain by about 19 points on a 100-point scale, and increased hair counts in women over 16 weeks. The key is the right type of light, at the right intensity, for long enough. If you want to use red light, we recommend FDA-approved Celluma.

4. “If There Is No Struggle, There Is No Progress”: How to Tell Normal Hard From a Real Warning Sign

Discomfort usually comes with real growth, and people who treat it as a sign of progress take more productive risks. In a field experiment with improv students, those told that feeling awkward meant the exercise was working took more risks. We assume that if something feels hard, something is wrong. Often, hard is what progress feels like from the inside.

The Positive Corner of The Internet
About Arnold’s Pump Club Editorial Standards

We do things a bit differently here, starting with transparency.

  1. The Content: All APC emails are researched, written, and fact-checked by the APC editors (see bottom of the email), with written contributions from Arnold (noted with “Arnold’s Corner”). Links take you to original studies (not second-hand sources).

  2. Does AI play a role? Not for the primary content, but we use it in two ways. The main items are original content written by the APC team. The summaries at the end are AI-generated based on the human-written content above. We also use an AI tool to edit and review our interpretations of the research, ensuring scientific accuracy. We don’t assume AI is right, but we use technology to hold ourselves accountable.

  3. Yes, we have partners (all clearly noted by “Together With”). Why? Because it allows us to keep the APC emails free. We first test products, and then reach out to potential partners who offer ways to help you improve every day. The bar is set high, and to date, we have turned down millions in ad deals. (Example: we will not partner with any non-certified supplements or those without evidence in human trials). If we won’t buy the product, we won’t recommend it to you. And if there’s no evidence it works, then there’s no place for it here.

—

Publisher: Arnold Schwarzenegger​

Editors-in-chief: Adam Bornstein and Daniel Ketchell


Get Arnold's Official Merch