Together With David
Here's something that doesn't add up:
Americans spend more than $9 billion every year on protein bars and supplements. That's a lot of money chasing one simple goal: eat more protein, build more muscle, feel better.
And yet, most people still aren't hitting their protein targets. And a lot of protein bars aren’t living up to their given reputations.
Research suggests that many of us are being misled about what we're actually getting when we buy these products.
That "20g protein" bar you grabbed at the gas station? Depending on what's inside, your muscles might only be able to use a fraction of those 20 grams. Some bars — despite their impressive labels— deliver a fraction of what the label suggests.
Here's the good news: this isn't a "protein bars are bad" story. Bars are convenient, they travel well, and when you're rushing between meetings or picking up kids from practice, sometimes a bar is the only realistic option. We get it. Life is busy.
The problem isn't protein bars. The problem is that some companies are taking advantage of confusing labels to sell you products that don't deliver what they promise.
Today, we're going to fix that. By the time you finish reading this, you'll understand the two things that actually matter when it comes to protein (in the right order of priority), and you'll have a simple 5-second test you can use to cut through the marketing noise and find bars that actually work.
No complicated science. No guilt trips about "eating real food." Just the truth and a plan.
The Two Things That Actually Matter
When it comes to protein, most people obsess over the wrong details. They worry about timing, whether whey is better than casein, and whether they should eat protein within 30 minutes of their workout.
Here's what the research actually shows: two factors matter far more than anything else, and they work in a specific order.
Priority #1: Your total daily protein intake
This is the big one. How much protein you eat across the entire day matters more than any other factor: more than timing, more than the specific source, more than whether you drink a shake or eat a steak.
If you want your body to change, the amount of protein you eat each day is the closest thing you have to a guarantee.
A massive meta-analysis — 74 randomized controlled trials, more than 5,400 participants — found a simple truth: The more protein people ate (up to a certain point), the more lean muscle they gained.
Another meta-analysis of more than 100 trials confirmed the same pattern: muscle growth increases predictably until you reach around 1.3 g/kg/day and then continues (at a slower pace) up to 2.2 grams per kilogram per day, assuming you’re active and resistance training.
In other words, you’ll want anywhere from .6 to 1 gram per pound of your goal bodyweight.
Here’s what your daily protein intake should look like based on your body weight:
If you weigh 140 lbs, aim for 85–140g/day
If you weigh 160 lbs, aim for 95–160g/day
If you weigh 180 lbs, aim for 110–180g/day
If you weigh 200 lbs, aim for 120–200g/day
A high-protein bar can be a great tool to help you achieve your protein goals, but it’s not the foundation. After all, a 20-gram bar might only be 10 or 15 percent of your daily target.
Protein bars should make your life easier. They should help you hit your totals. But they are supplements to your effort, not shortcuts.
Get the total right first. Everything else is secondary.
Priority #2: Protein quality
Once you're hitting your daily target, the quality of your protein sources starts to matter more. And this is where things get interesting, and where a lot of people are unknowingly getting shortchanged.
There are several ways to measure protein digestibility. PDCAAS (Protein Digestibility-Corrected Amino Acid Score) was the gold standard until about 10 years ago. PDCAAS measures digestibility based on what exits your body, not what's actually absorbed in your small intestine. But with a perfect score of 1.0, you can usually tell that you’ve found a high-quality source of protein. While PDCAAs remain valuable and indicate protein quality, there is a more accurate way to measure protein quality.
Scientists can also measure protein quality using something called DIAAS (Digestible Indispensable Amino Acid Score). The concept is simple: DIAAS tells you how much of the protein you eat actually gets absorbed and used by your muscles.
Unlike older methods that measured what came out the other end, DIAAS measures amino acid absorption where it actually happens. This gives a much more precise picture of what your body is actually getting.
It also focuses on essential amino acids. Your body needs nine essential amino acids to build muscle, and it needs them in specific proportions. Scientists compare how much of each essential amino acid a food delivers (after digestion) against a standardized reference of what your body requires.
DIAAS finds the "limiting" amino acid because your body can only build muscle protein as fast as the scarcest essential amino acid allows.
Think of it like building a wall with nine different types of bricks (the essential amino acids): if you run out of one type (the limiting amino acid), construction stops, no matter how many of the other eight you have piled up. The DIAAS score is based on whichever amino acid is in shortest supply relative to what you need.
Here's how common protein sources stack up:
Whey protein isolate: 1.09 (excellent—more than 100% of what you need)
Soy protein isolate: 0.90 (good)
Pea protein concentrate: 0.82 (moderate)
Rice protein: 0.37 (low)
Collagen: 0 (essentially zero for muscle building)
What Low DIAAS Scores Actually Mean (This Is Important)
Here's where we need to be careful, because this is often misunderstood: a low DIAAS score doesn't mean a protein is worthless. It means that protein is less efficient at stimulating muscle protein synthesis on its own.
The amino acids in lower-DIAAS proteins are still absorbed. They still contribute to your overall amino acid pool. They can still support other functions in your body. They just aren't as effective — gram for gram — at the specific job of building and maintaining muscle tissue.
So if muscle building is your primary goal when you grab a protein bar, a bar with high-DIAAS protein is like putting premium fuel in the tank. A bar with low-DIAAS protein might technically add "20 grams of protein" to your daily intake, but your muscles can only use a fraction of that for their main purpose.
Collagen is a perfect example. It scores zero for muscle building because it lacks tryptophan, one of the nine essential amino acids. Without tryptophan, muscle protein synthesis can't proceed, no matter how much collagen you consume. But that doesn't mean collagen is useless. Research suggests it may support skin elasticity, joint health, and connective tissue. It's just not doing what you think it's doing when you see "20g protein" on the label and assume that's helping you build muscle.
If you're eating a varied diet with multiple protein sources throughout the day, some lower-DIAAS proteins mixed in won't hurt you. The amino acids from different foods can complement each other.
But if you're specifically buying a protein bar to help you hit your muscle-building protein target — and paying a premium for it — you want a bar to contain proteins that actually do that job efficiently.
The Power of Protein Combining
This is where it gets interesting. Different protein sources have different limitations:
Pea protein is low in methionine but high in lysine
Rice protein is low in lysine but adequate in methionine
When you combine them, each fills in what the other is missing. That's why many plant-based protein bars use pea-rice blends—together, they create a more complete amino acid profile than either one alone.
This same principle applies to your whole diet. You don't need every single meal to be perfectly balanced in amino acids. If you eat a variety of protein sources across the day — some eggs at breakfast, chicken at lunch, maybe a plant-based bar as a snack, fish at dinner — your body has access to all the essential amino acids it needs.
The concern with low-quality protein bars isn't that they're harmful. It's that if you're relying on them as a significant protein source, you might be falling short of your muscle-building goals without realizing it. You're paying for protein that isn't fully doing its job.
Why Labels Mislead (And How to Spot The Deception)
A study published in March 2025 in Scientific Reports analyzed 1,641 protein bars from around the world. The researchers wanted to know: do these bars actually deliver the protein quality their labels promise?
Of all the bars analyzed, 81% technically met the criteria to be labeled "high in protein." Sounds good, right?
But when the researchers measured actual protein quality using DIAAS, even the best-performing bars scored only 61% — well below the 75% threshold the Food and Agriculture Organization recommends for making protein quality claims.
The worst bars? They scored below 10%. That means for every 20 grams of protein on the label, your muscles might be getting the equivalent of less than 2 grams of usable amino acids.
In many cases, the culprit was collagen. Bars that featured collagen as a primary protein source had the highest protein claims on the front of the package, but the lowest actual protein quality when tested in the lab.
And here's something that might surprise you: many products labeled "beef protein isolate" are actually just collagen with a fancier name. Beef protein isolate is often derived from connective tissues, bones, and hides, not muscle meat. The amino acid profile is nearly identical to gelatin.
So if you see "beef protein isolate" high on an ingredient list, don't assume you're getting the protein equivalent of a steak. True muscle-meat-derived beef protein would score higher, but these products are uncommon and more expensive.
There's another issue worth knowing about. Even when bars use high-quality proteins like whey or casein, the other ingredients in the bar can reduce how much your body actually absorbs. Researchers call this the "matrix effect." When protein gets trapped in a bar alongside sugars, digestibility drops.
None of this means you should swear off protein bars forever. It means you should know what to look for.
The 5-Second Flip Test
Here's a simple system you can use the next time you're standing in the grocery aisle or scrolling through Amazon trying to decide if a protein bar is worth your money.
Flip the bar over. Look at two things:
First, check the protein source. Look at the first ingredient. You want to see: whey protein isolate, whey protein concentrate, milk protein, casein, egg white protein, or soy protein isolate. These are complete proteins that your muscles can actually use.
Solid alternatives: Pea and rice protein blends can work well together (each compensates for the other's amino acid weaknesses). They're not quite as effective as dairy or egg proteins, but they're a reasonable choice, especially if you're avoiding dairy.
Second, check the protein-to-sugar ratio. Here's a simple rule: protein grams should be at least double the sugar grams, and ideally higher. If a bar has 20 grams of protein and more than 10 grams of sugar, you can probably find a better option.
Natural sugars from dates or dried fruit are metabolized a bit differently than added sugars, but the ratio still matters. And most of the highest-sugar bars aren't from fruit sugar; they are just protein bars moonlighting as candy bars with better marketing.
The whole process takes about five seconds. With practice, you'll be able to spot a winner almost instantly.
When Bars Make the Most Sense
Protein bars aren't meant to be the foundation of your nutrition. But they're genuinely helpful in certain situations:
The post-workout window, when you're heading straight to work or picking up kids and can't sit down for a meal.
Travel days when airport food options are limited and overpriced.
Busy afternoons when you realize at 3 pm that you've barely eaten and dinner is still hours away.
Emergency backup in your desk drawer, gym bag, or car for those days when everything goes sideways.
In these moments, a quality protein bar that delivers 20+ grams of usable protein is genuinely helpful. It's not about being perfect; it's about having a reliable tool that helps you stay consistent.
Once you understand the science, the industry looks different.
You stop falling for big numbers on wrappers.
You stop buying “nutrition bars” that are glorified candy bars.
You start looking for quality, digestibility, and simplicity.
That’s why — when we choose a bar for ourselves and our community — we look for:
High-quality protein sources
Reasonable sugar-to-protein ratios
Ingredient lists that make sense
A formula designed for actual digestibility
David checks those boxes with 28 grams of protein, 150 calories, and 0 grams of sugar. With 75 percent of its calories from protein, it’s 50% higher than the next closest protein bar. David provides a blend of diverse protein sources that creates a perfect 1.0 Protein Digestibility-Corrected Amino Acid Score (PDCAAS), making it ideal for muscle building and overall health.
David is the perfect on-the-go solution for anyone who struggles to eat enough protein and needs a convenient option that doesn’t waste calories.
David was sold out for months, but it’s now back in stock. And, as an APC reader, if you buy four boxes, you’ll get your fifth box for free when you use this link.
The protein industry spends a lot of money trying to convince you that its products are essential. But the science tells a simpler story.
First, hit your daily protein target. That's the foundation everything else is built on.
Second, choose quality sources most of the time that your muscles can actually use.
Third, don't let marketing language fool you. "High protein" on a label doesn't mean the protein inside is high quality. Flip the bar over. Check the source. Look at the sugar. Scan the ingredients. And find the bar that’s right for you.
—
Publisher: Arnold Schwarzenegger
Editors-in-chief: Adam Bornstein and Daniel Ketchell
